United States

Computational modeling and video analysis are two powerful tools in the physics classroom for helping students analyze and model real-world phenomena. When we pair the two of these together in one web-based platform, students can use video analysis to construct a computational model that reproduces the data they measure from the video and gain new physical insights and understandings. Pivot interactives is one platform that allows for the integration of video analysis side by side with computational tools like Tychos, Glowscript, and Pyret.


AAPT SM 21

Computational Modeling &amp; Video Analysis in One Easy Environment

tychos

programming

computational modeling

high school physics

video analysis

Join AAPT and Physics Educators worldwide in developing and strengthening your professional connections by attending the 2021 AAPT Virtual Summer Meeting. AAPT meetings are a great way to reflect on your teaching, recommit to best practices and re-energize your career with new research, products, and techniques.

Listen to internationally known plenary speakers, attend sessions, workshops, and special activities. Attending the virtual summer meeting is an excellent opportunity to share your expertise and learn from and network with leaders in the field.

Please log in with your AAPT account or register for the event if you haven't already.

If you are registered please note that you need to be logged in with your AAPT email / credentials in order to get access.

Computational Modeling & Video Analysis in One Easy Environment

technical paper

Quantum mechanics instruction has remained unchanged for at least 75 years, following a coordinate-space-based formalism that requires significant class time for instruction on the mathematical background for the Frobenius method, delta functions, Fourier transforms, etc. This mathematics instruction, greatly limits the amount of physics that can be included. In this talk, I will tell you how to reverse this trend. In Fall 2020, I taught a one-semester quantum mechanics course at Georgetown that worked within a representation-independent formalism (emphasizing operators, not wavefunctions). It is mathematically simpler and frees up time for discussing conceptual and physical ideas. I discuss important experiments such as Stern-Gerlach, delayed choice, EPR, Bell inequality tests, Hong-Ou-Mandel, Pickering-Fowler lines, discovery of deuterium, proton radius, electron momentum spectroscopy, time of flight, hyperfine interactions and radio astronomy, cyclotron resonance and MRI, single-photon detection, homodyne detection, and LIGO. Come see how you can adopt this for your class too.

Bringing the physics back into the undergraduate quantum classroom

I will report on three practices I implemented in upper division electromagnetic theory courses to improve the impact of homework on student learning. The principal innovation was to adapt some of the principles of calibrated peer review, which has been demonstrated to be beneficial in writing assignments to common physics homework assignments. The other two innovations involved having the students complete the assignments using templates in Jupyter notebooks. This gave them an opportunity to present their homework in a professional manner and to check their symbolic answers against answer verification software running on a server. These innovations improved student persistence until mastery, encouraged students to study alternate approaches to problems, and increased the time students spent on analyzing what they did incorrectly on problems. I will report formal and informal feedback I received from students on the effectiveness of these innovations.

Improving Upper Division Homework Effectiveness

Research-based tutorials---worksheets that guide students in constructing physics knowledge for themselves---have repeatedly proven to be a highly effective complement to lectures in physics courses. Our collaboration has created a collection of tutorials for middle-division quantum mechanics (QM), which has been successfully adopted by QM instructors nationwide. However, many instructors lack the resources and/or institutional support to run tutorials; it can be difficult to find time, space, and personnel to facilitate these activities. As an alternative, we are developing online versions of our QM tutorials that students can work through without instructor facilitation. We are designing the online tutorials to guide students through the worksheets in ways that encourage sense-making and allow students to progress without revealing the answers. For example, they include adaptive guidance pathways based on students’ responses. Early beta versions are available, for free, at acephysics.net.

Online Tutorials for Middle-Division Quantum with Adaptive Guidance

Research-based assessments can provide instructors insights into the efficacy of their teaching and course transformations. As education shifts to focusing more on scientific practices and crosscutting concepts in addition to conceptual knowledge, there is a need for an assessment that can assess these 3-dimensions of learning and inform instructional approaches that foster this learning. In this talk, we present a first-look at an upper-division thermal physics assessment that explicitly targets scientific practices, crosscutting concepts, and conceptual knowledge using coupled, multiple-response items. We will present an example assessment item and discuss ways in which instructors can help with the development process of this assessment while incorporating it into their classrooms. Faculty administering the assessment would receive detailed feedback about their class’s overall performance with recommendations for how to adjust instruction to improve student outcomes.

A Knowledge-in-Use Assessment for Upper-Division Thermal Physics

We present preliminary mixed-methods results for an experiment upon a first-semester senior undergraduate electromagnetism course for physics majors, in which 25 students were given explicit incentive to rework mistakes from unit exams in a first-semester senior-level electromagnetism course. Three unit exam problems were revisited on the final exam. Initial quantitative results for one of the three problems (P1) showed a strong effect from unit exam to final, between students who reworked problems and students who chose not to; however, the other two problems (P2 and P3) presented a ceiling effect on unit exam performance that prevented pre-post analysis. Follow-up interviews with a small sample of students suggest a strong recall of their attempts on problems P1 and P2 despite being over a year removed from said exams; however, some did not recognize mistakes. We conclude by discussing plans for analysis of current/future data and adjustments to this ongoing study.

Rework and Recall: Exam Performance in Upper-division Electromagnetism

In order to help our students better understand the conceptual connections between spin states and wavefunctions in our junior-level, spins-first quantum course, we have recently begun to emphasize the use of completeness relations to write a state in a particular basis. We describe completeness relations as “special forms of 1” that can be used to project a quantum state vector onto a basis. Using a discrete spin bases, the expansion coefficients are interpreted as probabilities amplitudes. Using a continuous position basis, these probability amplitudes get “smeared out” to become a “probability amplitude density” (a.k.a., wavefunction), similar to how discrete point masses go to mass densities. In this talk, we will share the in-class activities and homework tasks we’ve developed to help students understand make these connections.


Using Completeness Relations to Help Students Understand Wavefunctions

Open and Individualized - Mechanics Homework Problems Project Using WeBWorK

Individualized homework problems delivered over the web are an effective way for students to learn first year mechanics. This is not news, but I learned how effective it was and that it is worth spending the time developing more problems as part of an open community. WeBWorK is an open-source on-line homework system that gives students instant feedback. It has better quiz options than most Learning Management Systems. WeBWorK has been used by the mathematics community for decades, but there are not many physics problems in the Open Problem Library (OPL) and less than 100 of the type needed for first and second-year physics and engineering students. I am a physics instructor at a two-year teaching college, but I ended up working with an engineering professor and coop students at UBC, a large research university We hope to have more people join us in this worthwhile project. 
I will present what I learned about WeBWorK, supervising coop students to create questions, and working with a professor from a large university to create open educational resources.

Open and Individualized - Mechanics Homework Problems Project Using WeBWorK

With the rise of the flipped (active) classroom, in addition to more courses moving online, the use of video as a form of instruction has increased substantially. This raises the question about the impact of this method of delivery on student learning. Under NSF funding, we have developed and evaluated multiple interactive video-enhanced tutorials (IVETs). The IVETs involve web-based activities that lead students through a problem solution using expert-like problem-solving approaches. As part of the IVET evaluation, we assigned one group of students to complete the IVETs as homework, while another group watched a video summary of the problem solving process. Both groups later completed a follow-up problem as a means of measuring impact on learning. Significant learning gains were observed for students in the IVET group compared to the Video-only group. Results from multiple IVETs will be shared along with suggestions for making videos more mentally engaging for students.
*Work supported by the NSF IUSE Program (DUE #1821396)


Video versus Interactive Video for Impact on Learning

When planning to take my calculus-based introduction to mechanics online, I had many small concerns, and two huge ones: tests and labs. In both cases, the solutions I found were imperfect, but contained elements that were improvements over the pre-pandemic versions. In this talk, I will focus on the labs. I replaced hands on labs with a mixture of simulations, computational exercises and labs using the sensors in students’ smartphones. While many students missed the “lab group experience” they were excited by the additional flexibility afforded by these labs, particularly those using their phones. I will discuss the benefits and shortcomings of all three of these lab formats but focus primarily on the phone-based labs, which I will be continuing to use post-pandemic.

Updating mechanics labs with technology for the pandemic and beyond

Nowadays computation stands alongside theory and experiment as one of the pillars of modern science, which is reflected in the fact that research and industry rely heavily on technology and computation. Therefore, we need to prepare graduates to integrate computation within their underlying discipline. In this study, we look at how academics across the College of Science at an Irish University use computational practices in their research. This will inform the design of a first-year undergraduate science course aimed at emphasizing the relevance of computational practices in science, by introducing them to authentic problems across the areas of science where computation is used and to make students competitive graduates in their respective fields.

Premium content

Downloads

Next from AAPT SM 21

Bringing the physics back into the undergraduate quantum classroom

Similar lecture

Teacher use of resources while integrating computational modeling into classrooms